One day, by chance, I came across Rory Sutherland, the Vice Chairman of Ogilvy, while browsing through YouTube. As I delved deeper into his content, the YouTube algorithm flooded me with more of his videos. Intrigued by his insights, I purchased his early book, "Alchemy." In this book, Sutherland, a prominent figure in advertising and a respected behavioural economist, introduces a thought-provoking concept. Titled Alchemy: The Surprising Power of Ideas That Don’t Make Sense, the book delves into the dual nature of human decision-making. Sutherland suggests that our actions are often influenced by two distinct rationales. The first rationale, the one we openly express, serves as a socially acceptable or logical justification for our behaviour. On the other hand, the second rationale, which Sutherland refers to as "the actual reason," explores our genuine motivations and aspirations.
This dichotomy proposed by Sutherland sheds light on the complexity of human behaviour and the intricacies of our decision-making processes. It suggests that our actions are not always driven by logical reasoning or societal norms but are often influenced by subconscious desires, emotions, and biases that may not be immediately apparent. By recognizing this distinction between the actual reason and the good reason behind our choices, we gain a deeper understanding of ourselves and others, paving the way for a more insightful analysis of human behaviour.
Explanation:
Actual Reason: This is the genuine, often subconscious motivation behind our actions. It might be driven by a complex interplay of emotions, past experiences, psychological factors, and deep-rooted beliefs. The actual reason often lurks beneath the surface, influencing our behaviour in ways we may not fully comprehend. It can stem from childhood traumas, unresolved conflicts, or even evolutionary instincts that shape our decisions without our conscious awareness.
Good Reason: In contrast, good reason represents the conscious, socially acceptable explanation we offer to others and ourselves. It serves as a polished facade, reflecting our desire to conform to societal standards and maintain a positive self-image. The good reason is tailored to fit cultural norms and expectations, presenting our actions in a favourable light and shielding us from judgment or criticism. While the good reason may not always align with our true motivations, it plays a crucial role in shaping how we are perceived by others and how we perceive ourselves within the social fabric.
Example1: Buying an expensive car
When contemplating the decision to purchase an expensive car, various factors come into play. On one hand, the actual reason behind such a choice often delves into deeper emotional and psychological realms. It could be driven by a desire for status, the exhilarating thrill of driving a powerful vehicle, or even a profound attachment to a particular brand that resonates with one's identity.
On the other hand, a more socially acceptable & good reason can be found in highlighting the practical benefits of the purchase. This includes emphasizing the car's advanced safety features that ensure the well-being of both the driver and passengers, its exceptional fuel efficiency that contributes to a greener environment, or its renowned reliability that promises a long-lasting investment.
Ultimately, the decision to invest in an expensive car is a complex interplay between personal desires, societal norms, and practical considerations. Understanding the underlying motivations can provide valuable insights into our values, aspirations, and priorities when it comes to such significant purchases.
Example2: Brushing our teeth
When considering the habit of brushing teeth, there are various layers to explore beyond the surface. While the actual reason for many may be avoiding social ostracism due to bad breath, the importance of dental hygiene goes much deeper. Brushing teeth is not merely a cosmetic routine to maintain social acceptance; it is a crucial practice that directly impacts our overall health and well-being.
One of the good reasons for brushing teeth is to prevent tooth decay and maintain oral health. By brushing regularly, we remove plaque and bacteria that can lead to cavities and gum disease. This preventive measure not only saves us from potential dental issues but also contributes to our general health. Poor oral hygiene has been linked to various systemic conditions, emphasizing the significance of proper dental care.
Moreover, the frequency of brushing plays a critical role in its effectiveness. While many individuals may limit brushing to once or twice a day, ideally, it is recommended to brush after every meal. This practice ensures that food particles are promptly removed, reducing the risk of bacterial growth and dental problems. Consistency in brushing habits is key to reaping the full benefits of oral hygiene.
Therefore, the act of brushing teeth transcends the superficial concern of social acceptance. It is a proactive measure that safeguards our dental health, contributes to our overall well-being, and underscores the importance of consistent oral hygiene practices.
Sutherland’s insight encourages us to recognize the complex interplay between our true motivations and the narratives we construct to justify them. It also underscores the importance of understanding human behaviour beyond mere logic and reason. Most of the time, we make a decision (actual reason) and then justify it with rational logic which seems like a good reason to the external world.
Feel free to share your thoughts on this article.
Comments